Ad
Ad unit reserved — ca-pub-2582995408460804 · header

Whatnot vs eBay: which keeps more?

Live auction energy vs the everything store — per sale.

Whatnot charges 8% commission plus 2.9% + $0.30 processing; eBay takes 13.6% final value fee plus $0.40 per order. Enter your item once and see which leaves more per sale.

Your item

$
$
$
$
%
%

Results

Enter your item to compare.

Whatnot — you keep

$0.00

Margin 0% · Fees $0.00

eBay — you keep

$0.00

Margin 0% · Fees $0.00

  • Fee assumptions as of$0.00

Fee assumptions

Last checked: September 2026 · Country: United States · Sources: Whatnot seller fee schedule · eBay selling fees

Category rates vary on both sides — eBay Motors is far lower than 13.6%, and Whatnot's electronics rate is 5%. Confirm your category before pricing.

Ad
Ad unit reserved — ca-pub-2582995408460804 · in-content

Why Whatnot usually wins on fees

Whatnot's 8% + ~2.9% + $0.30 lands around 11–12% all-in on a typical sale, versus eBay's 13.6% + $0.40. On a $30 item that's roughly $3.72 vs $5.16 — over a dollar per sale stays in your pocket. The gap narrows on very cheap items where the $0.30 processing minimum bites.

The format trade

Whatnot sells live — auctions, breaks, drops — which suits collectibles, cards, and anything with bidding energy. eBay's fixed-price and auction listings reach a far larger general buyer base. Fees decide margin; format decides what your inventory can actually do.

Time is a cost too

Live selling takes hours on camera; eBay listings sell while you sleep. If your time has a price, value the hours before declaring the fee winner the real winner.

Frequently asked questions

Is it cheaper to sell on Whatnot or eBay?

On fees alone, Whatnot usually: ~11–12% all-in (8% commission + 2.9% + $0.30) vs eBay's 13.6% + $0.40 per order. Run your item above — the gap is typically $1–2 per sale.

What are Whatnot's seller fees?

8% commission on the item price (4% for coins & money, 5% for electronics) plus 2.9% + $0.30 payment processing on the buyer's total. No listing fees.

What is eBay's final value fee?

13.6% of the total sale (item + shipping) for most categories, plus a $0.40 per-order fee on orders over $10 ($0.30 at or under). Some categories differ.

What sells best on Whatnot vs eBay?

Whatnot favors live-friendly categories: trading cards, collectibles, sneakers, and anything with break/auction energy. eBay's broader buyer base suits general merchandise and fixed-price listings.

Live energy vs the biggest audience

On fees alone, Whatnot usually wins: 8% plus processing lands around 11–12% all-in against eBay's 13.6% plus a per-order fee. But nobody chooses a marketplace on fees alone. Whatnot sells through live shows — auctions, breaks, drops — where bidding energy lifts prices on cards, collectibles, and sneakers. eBay reaches the largest general buyer base on earth and sells while you sleep. PlainCalc's comparison settles the fee half so you can weigh it honestly against format, audience, and the hours live selling demands.

The gap is widest in the middle: $20–$100 items, where Whatnot's lower percentage dominates and eBay's $0.40 per-order fee still stings. At the extremes the story changes — razor-thin on very cheap items where fixed fees bite both sides, and worth rechecking on high-ticket items where eBay's category rates and seller tiers can dip below the headline 13.6%.

Worked example: $30 item, $5 shipping

Inputs: $30 price, $5 shipping charged, $4 shipping cost, $12 item cost, 8% Whatnot commission, 13.6% eBay final value fee.

Whatnot: fees $3.72 ($2.40 commission + $1.32 processing on the $35 buyer total). Profit: $35 − $3.72 − $12 − $4 = $15.29 — a 43.7% margin.

eBay: final value fee $4.76 (13.6% of $35) + $0.40 per-order fee = $5.16. Profit: $35 − $5.16 − $12 − $4 = $13.84 — a 39.5% margin.

Whatnot keeps $1.45 more per sale. Across a 200-sale month that is $290 — real money, though still less than one good evening of eBay sales you would have missed while live. Fees decide margin; your calendar decides the rest. At a $100 price with free shipping, the gap widens: Whatnot fees $11.20 against eBay's $14.00, a $2.80 swing per sale — the middle is where live selling pays best.

More Whatnot vs eBay questions

What is the $0.40 on eBay's side?

A fixed per-order fee: $0.40 on orders over $10, $0.30 at or under. The calculator picks the right one automatically from your order total.

Why does the shipping I charge change the winner?

Both platforms fee the shipping you charge the buyer, so a $5 shipping charge inflates both fee bases. Put actual shipping in the "charged" row and your label cost in "cost" to keep the comparison honest.

Is eBay's promoted-listings fee included?

No — the promo percentage is set to 0% here. If you promote, add your rate: it stacks on the final value fee and can erase Whatnot's edge fast.

Is the product cost the same on both sides?

Yes. Item cost and shipping cost are identical inputs for both columns, so the comparison isolates platform fees. Everything else — your hours on camera, eBay listing effort — is yours to price separately.

How this is calculated

Whatnot side: your commission rate on the item price plus 2.9% + $0.30 processing on the buyer total. eBay side: your final-value percentage on the full order total (item + shipping charged) plus the per-order fee — $0.40 when the order exceeds $10, $0.30 otherwise — with promoted-listing spend set to zero. Both sides subtract the same item cost and shipping cost from the same order total, so profit and margin differences are pure platform-fee differences. The winner is the higher net profit; under half a cent is a tie.

Ad
Ad unit reserved — ca-pub-2582995408460804 · sticky mobile