Ad unit reserved — ca-pub-2582995408460804 · header
Amazon vs Etsy: which keeps more?
Prime reach vs handmade margins.
Amazon charges a referral fee plus FBA fulfillment; Etsy stacks transaction, processing, and listing fees. Enter your product once and see which marketplace leaves more per unit.
Etsy: 6.5% transaction + 3% + $0.25 processing + $0.20 listing (Offsite Ads off in this comparison)
FBA fees depend on size tier and weight — paste your exact fee from Amazon's revenue calculator. Amazon's monthly Professional ($39.99) or per-item ($0.99) plan choice also shifts the math at low volume.
Ad
Ad unit reserved — ca-pub-2582995408460804 · in-content
Fulfillment is the swing factor
Etsy leaves fulfillment to you; Amazon FBA does it for a per-unit fee that includes Prime shipping. On small, light products the FBA fee is modest and Amazon's 15% referral is the main cost. On heavy or oversized products, the FBA fee alone can exceed Etsy's entire fee stack — that's where Etsy wins even before audience differences.
Don't forget the plan fee
Amazon's $39.99/month Professional plan (or $0.99/item Individual) isn't in the per-unit math. At 10 units a month it's $4/unit; at 1,000 it's $0.04. Add it to your mental margin at low volume.
Brand control vs reach
Etsy buyers expect handmade and small-batch; Amazon buyers expect Prime speed and easy returns. The fee winner and the business winner aren't always the same — but at least now you know the fee half exactly.
Frequently asked questions
Is Amazon or Etsy cheaper for sellers?
On fees alone, Etsy usually wins per unit — roughly 10% all-in vs Amazon's 15% referral plus FBA fulfillment. But FBA includes Prime shipping and handling you'd pay for yourself on Etsy.
What is Amazon's referral fee?
Typically 15% of the sale price for many categories ($0.30 minimum), but it varies widely — 8% for some electronics, up to 45% for certain accessories. Check your category.
What does FBA cost per item?
Depends on size and weight tier — roughly $3–$7+ for standard small items. Use Amazon's revenue calculator for your exact product.
Can I sell the same product on both?
Yes, and many sellers do — price for each platform's fee structure rather than using one price everywhere.
Amazon or Etsy: following the money on one sale
Choosing between Amazon and Etsy is really choosing between two different cost structures wearing two different audiences. Amazon charges a bigger referral percentage and adds a per-unit fulfillment fee, but it ships Prime-fast and puts the listing in front of buyers who were never searching for you. Etsy charges a lighter stack — a listing fee, a transaction percentage, and payment processing — but the packing, the postage, and the customer messages land on your kitchen table. This comparison settles the fee half of the question for a single item: enter the price, what you charge for shipping, what shipping actually costs you, your product cost, your Amazon referral rate, and the FBA fee, and PlainCalc shows each channel's net profit and margin side by side. Run it when a product could live on either marketplace, when you are deciding where to send ad traffic, or when an Etsy shop is doing well enough that Amazon's reach starts looking tempting.
Worked example: $39.99 home-decor item
Say the item sells for $39.99. You charge the buyer $4.95 for shipping, postage costs you $4.60, the item costs $11 to make, the Amazon category takes 15%, and the FBA fee for the size tier is $6.81. On the Etsy side, the engine builds an order total of $44.94 and subtracts $4.72 in fees — the $0.20 listing fee, 6.5% transaction on the order total, and 3% plus $0.25 processing — then takes off the $11 product cost and $4.60 shipping cost, leaving a net profit of $24.62 and a 54.8% margin. On the Amazon side, the referral fee comes to $6.00 and total Amazon fees to $12.81; after the same $4.60 shipping cost is deducted for a fair comparison, net profit lands at $11.58 with a 29.0% margin. The verdict: Etsy keeps you $13.04 more per sale on these inputs — a gap driven mostly by the $6.81 FBA fee.
Common questions
Why does the Amazon side subtract my shipping cost too?
The engine deducts your entered shipping cost on both sides by design. Since the FBA fee already covers delivery to the buyer, charging your own postage cost against the Amazon side is the conservative choice — it assumes you still bear shipping somewhere in the operation. If your Amazon shipments are fully covered by FBA with nothing extra out of pocket, zero out the shipping-cost field and rerun to see the optimistic case.
Is the $39.99-a-month Professional plan in the math?
No. Neither Amazon plan fee is modeled, so at low volume add it back yourself: $39.99 spread over 20 monthly sales is about $2.00 a unit, while over 500 sales it is 8 cents. The Individual plan's $0.99 per item is easier to handle — treat it as an extra dollar of product cost before you compare.
What if I offer free shipping on Etsy?
Enter zero for shipping charged. Etsy's transaction and processing fees then apply to the item price alone, while your real postage still comes out through the shipping-cost field. The Amazon side does not use the shipping-charged field at all, so it is unaffected.
Do either side include sales tax or VAT?
No. Both engines model marketplace fees and your own costs only; tax collection and remittance sit outside the arithmetic. If taxes meaningfully change your pricing, handle them in a separate step after the fee comparison.
How this is calculated
For Etsy, the engine sets the order total to price plus shipping charged, then computes fees as a $0.20 listing fee plus 6.5% of the order total plus 3% of the order total plus $0.25 processing. Net profit is the order total minus all fees, minus product cost, minus shipping cost; margin divides that net by the order total. For Amazon, the referral fee is the selling price times your rate (with the $0.30 floor), plus your FBA fee; net profit is the price minus those fees minus product cost minus shipping cost, and margin divides by the price. The verdict subtracts Amazon's net from Etsy's — a gap under half a cent reads as a tie.
Ad
Ad unit reserved — ca-pub-2582995408460804 · sticky mobile