Ad unit reserved — ca-pub-2582995408460804 · header
1099 vs W-2 calculator
A $140K contract is not a $140K salary.
Contract pay looks bigger because nothing is withheld — but you owe both halves of payroll tax and buy your own benefits. Enter both offers to see which actually leaves you ahead per year.
Results
Enter both offers to compare.
W-2 net (after tax + benefits)$0.00
W-2 salary$0.00
W-2 benefits value$0.00
W-2 tax + FICA$0.00
W-2 all-in rate$0.00
1099 net (after tax + benefits)$0.00
1099 net earnings$0.00
Self-employment tax$0.00
Income tax$0.00
Benefits you buy$0.00
Business expenses$0.00
Rule of thumb: 1099 pay needs to be roughly 25–30% higher than a W-2 salary to break even after SE tax and benefits.
Ad
Ad unit reserved — ca-pub-2582995408460804 · in-content
Where the contract premium goes
A 1099 contractor owes about 14.13% in effective self-employment tax (both halves of Social Security and Medicare on 92.35% of net earnings) versus 7.65% FICA as an employee — roughly a 6.5-point gap before income tax even starts. Then add health insurance, retirement contributions with no match, unpaid time off, and business expenses. A $140K contract against a $95K salary with $18K in benefits is often close to a tie, not a raise.
What the math misses
Stability, unemployment insurance, workers' comp, paid leave, and career growth don't fit in a calculator. Neither does flexibility, rate growth, or the ability to deduct business expenses. Use the number as a starting point, then price the intangibles yourself.
Quarterly taxes are the trap
Nothing is withheld from 1099 pay. If the contract wins, set up quarterly estimated payments immediately — the calculator's tax buffer is what you'd owe, and the IRS charges penalties for underpayment.
Frequently asked questions
How much more should 1099 pay vs W-2?
Roughly 25–30% more to break even after self-employment tax and self-funded benefits. Run your exact offers above — the gap varies with benefit values.
What is self-employment tax?
Social Security and Medicare on 92.35% of net earnings — effectively about 14.13%, versus 7.65% FICA for employees. It's the biggest structural cost of 1099 work.
Do 1099 contractors get benefits?
Not from the client — you buy health insurance, fund your own retirement, and take unpaid time off. Price all of it in the benefits row.
Is 1099 or W-2 better for taxes?
1099 unlocks business deductions (home office, mileage, equipment, half of SE tax) that can narrow the gap. W-2 is simpler and includes employer-paid benefits. The calculator compares after-tax outcomes.
The headline gap lies to you
A $140,000 contract next to a $95,000 salary looks like a $45,000 raise. It is not. The contractor pays both halves of Social Security and Medicare — about 14.13% effective self-employment tax against the employee's 7.65% — then buys their own health insurance, funds retirement with no match, and takes unpaid time off. PlainCalc's W-2 vs 1099 calculator is for the offer-comparison moment: it puts both deals on an after-tax, after-benefits footing so you compare net reality to net reality.
The benefits rows do the quiet work. Enter the dollar value of the W-2 benefits package (insurance premiums the employer pays, the match, paid-leave value); on the 1099 side, enter what those same things cost you out of pocket. That is where most "contract premiums" evaporate. And nothing is withheld from 1099 pay — if the contract wins, set up quarterly estimated payments the same week you sign.
W-2 net: $95,000 × (1 − 0.18 − 0.0765) = $70,632.50 after taxes, plus $18,000 in benefits = $88,632.50.
1099: net earnings $132,000 after expenses. Self-employment tax: $132,000 × 14.13% = $18,651.60. Income tax: $132,000 × 18% = $23,760.00. After self-funded benefits: $132,000 − $18,651.60 − $23,760 − $12,000 = $77,588.40.
The $45,000 headline shrinks to an $11,044.10 W-2 advantage. The contract would need roughly $11,000 more gross — or much lower expenses — to pull even. Tweak the expenses row and watch how fast the verdict moves: every deductible dollar saves you twice, against both taxes. If the contractor trims expenses to $3,000, net earnings rise to $137,000 and the W-2 lead narrows to $7,650.60 — still the employee's deal, but a much closer call.
More W-2 vs 1099 questions
What does "effective 14.13%" mean?
Self-employment tax is 15.3% on 92.35% of net earnings — the IRS excludes the employer half from the base — which works out to about 14.13% of net earnings. The calculator applies it as a flat effective rate, the same simplification the freelancer calculator uses.
Why are contractor benefits subtracted instead of added?
Because you pay for them yourself — they are a cost of the contract, not a perk. The W-2 benefits row is added (value you receive); the 1099 benefits row is subtracted (cost you bear). Mixing up the signs is the most common way to misread this comparison.
What tax rate should I type?
Your effective income-tax rate — total income tax divided by income — not your marginal bracket. A 22% bracket rarely means a 22% effective rate, and typing the bracket overstates what you owe.
Is this tax advice?
No. It is a planning comparison using flat rates and your own inputs. State taxes, deductions like the home office, and the deductible half of self-employment tax are simplified or ignored — a tax professional earns their fee on the details.
How this is calculated
W-2 net = salary × (1 − income-tax% − 7.65% FICA) + benefits value, floored at zero. 1099 net = (gross − expenses) − 14.13% self-employment tax on that amount − income-tax% on that amount − self-funded benefits, floored at zero. The verdict is 1099 net minus W-2 net; differences under half a cent count as a tie. Business expenses shrink the 1099 taxable base before both taxes are computed, which is why the expenses row moves the needle twice. Negative results are floored at zero per side before the difference is taken, so extreme inputs cannot manufacture a phantom winner.
Ad
Ad unit reserved — ca-pub-2582995408460804 · sticky mobile