Shopify fees worked example: 200 orders at $45
A store doing 200 orders a month at a $45 average order value brings in $9,000 in revenue. After the Basic plan, payment processing, product costs, and shipping, it keeps $3,840 — a 42.7% margin.
The breakdown
- Revenue: 200 × $45 = $9,000
- Payment processing: 200 × ($45 × 2.9% + $0.30) = 200 × $1.605 = $321.00
- Basic plan: $39.00
- Product costs: 200 × $18 = $3,600
- Shipping costs: 200 × $6 = $1,200
- Profit you keep: $9,000 − $321 − $39 − $3,600 − $1,200 = $3,840
- Effective platform cut: ($321 + $39) ÷ $9,000 = 4.0%
Notice how small the platform's share is at this volume: 4.0% all-in. At 50 orders a month the same $39 plan would be 1.7% of revenue by itself — Shopify rewards scale. Run your own volume in the Shopify profit calculator to find your break-even month.
Why the plan choice is the real question
Shopify inverts the marketplace model: instead of a per-sale commission, you rent the storefront for a flat monthly fee and pay processing on each order. That makes the plan tier — not the transaction — the decision that moves the answer. On 200 orders at $45, the $39 Basic subscription is just 39 ÷ 9000 = 0.43% of revenue, and the all-in platform cut is the 4.0% quoted above.
Grow costs $66 more per month than Basic ($105 − $39) and shaves 0.2 points off the online processing rate (2.9% → 2.7%): 66 ÷ 0.002 = $33,000 in monthly card volume is the rough point where Grow pays for itself.
Verified line by line
Revenue: 200 × $45 = $9,000. Processing per order: 45 × 0.029 = $1.305, plus $0.30 = $1.605; across 200 orders that is 200 × 1.605 = $321.00. Plan: $39.00. Product: 200 × $18 = $3,600. Shipping: 200 × $6 = $1,200. Profit: 9,000 − 321 − 39 − 3,600 − 1,200 = $3,840, and 3,840 ÷ 9,000 = 42.67%, the 42.7% margin above.
For perspective, the same $9,000 as 200 Etsy orders at 6.5% + 3% + $0.25 + $0.20 would cost $945 — 10.5% of revenue — versus Shopify's $360 (4.0%). Test your own volume in the Shopify profit calculator.
What changes the answer
Only 50 orders a month. Revenue = 50 × 45 = $2,250. Processing: 50 × 1.605 = $80.25. Plan: $39. Product: 50 × 18 = $900. Shipping: 50 × 6 = $300. Profit = 2,250 − 80.25 − 39 − 900 − 300 = $930.75, a 41.4% margin — the platform cut rises to (80.25 + 39) ÷ 2,250 = 5.3%.
Grow plan at the same 200 orders. Processing per order: 45 × 0.027 + 0.30 = $1.515; × 200 = $303.00. Platform total = 303 + 105 = $408 versus $360 on Basic — 4.5% effective instead of 4.0%. Upgrading early costs $48 a month here; the math only flips past roughly $33,000 in monthly volume.
Shopify revises plan prices and processing rates from time to time — check the current pricing page before committing to a tier.
Open Shopify profit calculator
Frequently asked questions
How much does Shopify take on $9,000 in sales?
On Basic: $321 in payment processing (2.9% + $0.30 per order × 200 orders) plus the $39 plan — $360 total, a 4.0% effective platform cut.
What is a good profit margin for Shopify?
After product, shipping, plan, and processing, 20–40% is healthy. This example keeps 42.7% thanks to a $27 gross margin per order.
When should I upgrade from Shopify Basic?
Roughly when the 0.2-point processing saving covers the $66/month jump — around $33,000/month in card volume through Shopify Payments.
Do third-party gateways change this?
Yes — they add 2.0% of order value on Basic ($180 here), which would cut profit to $3,660. Shopify Payments avoids that fee.
How much of the processing fee is the $0.30 fixed part?
On a $45 order it is $60 of the $321 total (18.7%). At a $15 average order value it would be a far bigger share — the fixed piece punishes small baskets.
What if I only get 10 orders a month?
The $39 plan alone is 8.7% of $450 in revenue. Processing adds 10 × $1.605 = $16.05, for a 12.2% platform cut before product and shipping costs. Subscription pricing punishes very low volume — profit would be $154.95 on this cost structure.
Is Shopify cheaper than Etsy at any volume?
Not at any volume, but here the gap is wide: $360 (4.0%) on Shopify versus $945 (10.5%) if the same $9,000 ran through Etsy at 6.5% + 3% + $0.25 + $0.20 per order. The crossover depends on your order count and average ticket — run both calculators.