Ad
Ad unit reserved — ca-pub-2582995408460804 · header

Etsy vs eBay: which keeps more?

Same item, two marketplaces, one winner.

Enter your item once. We run it through both fee structures — Etsy's listing + transaction + processing fees versus eBay's final value fee — and declare a winner on profit per sale.

Your item

$
$
$
$
%
Most categories 13.6%

Results

Enter your item to compare.

Etsy — you keep

$0.00

Margin 0% · Fees $0.00

eBay — you keep

$0.00

Margin 0% · Fees $0.00

  • Fee assumptions as of$0.00

Fee assumptions

Last checked: September 2026 · Country: United States · Source: Etsy fee schedule (eBay: ebay.com/help/selling/fees)

Category rates vary on both platforms — eBay Motors, for example, is far lower. Confirm your category's rate on each official fee page.

Ad
Ad unit reserved — ca-pub-2582995408460804 · in-content

Why the winner changes with price

Etsy stacks four small fees (listing, transaction, processing, sometimes Offsite Ads) while eBay takes one big final value fee plus a per-order charge. On cheap items Etsy's $0.20 listing and $0.25 processing minimums bite harder; on expensive items eBay's 13.6% dominates. There's no universal winner — only a winner for your item at your price.

Fees aren't the whole decision

Audience, listing tools, promoted placements, and how fast things sell all matter. A marketplace that keeps $2 less per sale but sells twice as fast wins on cash flow. Use this calculator for the fee half, then weigh velocity yourself.

Offsite Ads: Etsy's wildcard

If Etsy runs Offsite Ads on your listing, 12–15% comes off the top of attributed sales — enough to flip most comparisons. Toggle it above to see your worst case.

Frequently asked questions

Is it cheaper to sell on Etsy or eBay?

It depends on the item. Etsy's stacked fees (6.5% + 3% + $0.25 + $0.20/listing) vs eBay's 13.6% + $0.40 per order cross over at different price points — run your item above.

What is eBay's final value fee?

13.6% of the total sale (item + shipping) for most categories, plus a $0.40 per-order fee on orders over $10 ($0.30 at or under). Some categories differ.

What are Etsy's fees per sale?

6.5% transaction fee + 3% + $0.25 payment processing + $0.20 per listing, plus 12–15% Offsite Ads fee when a sale is attributed to Etsy's ads.

Which marketplace sells faster?

Category-dependent. eBay's auction format and larger buyer base often move commodity items faster; Etsy's search favors handmade and vintage. Fees decide margin; velocity decides cash flow.

One item, two fee stacks

This calculator pits Etsy's stacked fees against eBay's single big one for the exact item you're holding. Etsy's cut arrives as four small lines — $0.20 listing, 6.5% transaction, 3% + $0.25 processing, sometimes Offsite Ads — while eBay takes 13.6% of the order plus a per-order fee. Because Etsy's fixed minimums bite hardest on cheap items and eBay's 13.6% dominates on expensive ones, the winner changes with price: there is a crossover point, and this tool finds your side of it.

Walked-through example

Price a handmade piece at $32 with $4 charged shipping, a $3.75 label, and $11 in materials; keep eBay at 13.6% and Etsy offsite-free. The $36.00 order costs $3.87 on Etsy ($0.20 listing + $2.34 transaction + $1.33 processing), leaving $17.38 at a 48.3% margin. On eBay the same $36.00 order costs $4.90 in final value fees plus the $0.40 per-order fee — $5.30 total — leaving $15.95 at a 44.3% margin. Etsy keeps about $1.43 more on this item. Raise the price to $80 and rerun it: eBay's percentage-heavy cut usually takes the lead back.

Questions specific to this comparison

Does the Etsy side include the listing fee? Yes — one $0.20, as if this sale renews the listing once. High-volume single listings should mentally shave a few cents off Etsy's fee total.

Why no ad spend fields? Promoted listings and Etsy Ads are optional and seller-set, so the comparison stays apples-to-apples on platform fees. Heavy promoters should add their rate to the relevant side afterward.

Is a $1.43 win worth switching platforms? Maybe not alone. A platform that sells the item twice as fast can beat a $1.43 fee edge on cash flow — fees decide margin, velocity decides how often you collect it.

What flips the verdict most often? The Offsite Ads toggle: a 15% attributed sale adds roughly $5 to Etsy's side here, enough to hand the win to eBay outright.

How this is calculated

The Etsy path runs the full stack — $0.20 listing, 6.5% transaction on the order total, 3% + $0.25 processing, plus any offsite rate you select — against your materials and shipping cost. The eBay path takes 13.6% of the order total plus the $0.40 or $0.30 per-order fee (chosen by the $10 threshold) against the same costs. Each side's keep is order dollars minus its fees minus costs; the verdict reports the difference.

Ad
Ad unit reserved — ca-pub-2582995408460804 · sticky mobile